On November 19, the board of the REALTORS® Association of Edmonton will ask members to approve applying for direct membership in CREA, with a date for notice to AREA. The meeting package explains it in one sentence.
Vote no on Motions 5 and 8Every video uses RAE's own documents or the RAE Chair's written replies to members.
What RAE's Chair has told members, set against what the motions and bylaws say.
How Motion 8 reached the agenda after the notice of meeting had gone out.
Motion 5 makes two changes. Members were told about one.
The Chair's own list of what would have to be replaced.
Six questions to put to your board before you vote.
The meeting package sent to members has six documents. This is everything it says about what Motion 8 would do.

The notice of meeting went to members without Motion 8. Less than an hour later a second email arrived. It did not say what had changed.
The agenda in this package runs from the bylaw motions straight to the Chair's Report.


This is all the second email says about the change.


Direct CREA membership, inserted ahead of the Chair's Report.

Motion 5 was called membership maintenance. It makes two changes involving AREA. The board's summary describes one of them: dues. The other removes AREA membership itself, and it appears only in the redline.



The email does not mention AREA.
Section 3. An outdated requirement to pay AREA dues through RAE is removed. Nobody disputes this one.

Section 7 is not about dues. Today it says your application to RAE includes membership in AREA and CREA. Motion 5 strikes it out and replaces it with section 14, which enrols you in CREA only.
It is not in the September 21 email. It is not in the board's summary. It appears only in the redline.



AREA comes out of your bylaws before you have seen a plan, a cost, or a reason.

Proposed bylaw changes raise serious questions about AREA membership, transparency and the future plan for members.
There are significant changes being proposed at the upcoming General Meeting, and we believe members deserve more information before they are asked to vote.
The issue is not simply whether bylaws should be updated. Organizations need to evolve, and bylaws sometimes need to change.
The concern is what these particular changes appear to do, how they are being presented to members, and what happens afterward.
We have questions. Members deserve answers.
The updated GM agenda was provided then an update shortly after not identifying the proposed changes and appropriate transparency to consider their implications.
At the same time, the proposed bylaw changes appear to create a path to remove our organization’s membership relationship with the Alberta Real Estate Association (AREA) without clearly stating that this is what is being proposed.
If that is the intended outcome, why isn't it being clearly presented to members?
And if it isn't the intended outcome, what exactly will these changes do?
These are reasonable questions for members to ask before voting on changes that could have a significant and lasting impact on how we do business.
Before making a major change, members should be able to understand the problem being solved and the benefit they can expect to receive.
Right now, that picture isn't clear.
What will members gain?
If our relationship with AREA changes:
Most importantly: Where is the plan?
We have seen proposed changes to the bylaws, but we have not seen a clear, detailed plan explaining what the organization will look like afterward and how members will be better served.
A vote on the bylaws should not have to be a vote based on assumptions about what might happen next.
A bylaw can sound administrative.
But when a bylaw change affects an organization's membership structure, relationships and obligations, the consequences can be much bigger than the wording on the page suggests.
That's why members should be asking:
What does this actually change?
Why is it being changed now?
Who benefits from the change?
What happens the day after it passes?
What happens if the proposed alternative doesn't work?
And perhaps most importantly:
Why aren't members being given a clear plan before being asked to approve it?
Even if you ultimately support the proposed changes, members should have enough information and enough time to make an informed decision.
The timing of the updated agenda makes that difficult.
Members should have a reasonable opportunity to:
This isn't about opposing change for the sake of opposing change.
It's about expecting transparency before a significant decision is made.
We are asking the organization to provide clear answers to some basic questions before members vote:
We believe members should be able to answer three basic questions before voting:
What am I voting for?
Why am I voting for it?
What happens next?
Right now, there are too many unanswered questions.
That doesn't necessarily mean the proposed changes are wrong.
It does mean members deserve the information needed to decide for themselves.
This is your organization.
If you are an Edmonton member, you have a direct interest in understanding what is being proposed and what it could mean for you, your business and your profession.
Don't assume someone else will ask the questions.
Attend the GM.
Ask questions.
Listen to the answers.
Read the proposed bylaws.
Talk to other members.
And most importantly:
VOTE.
Whatever your position ultimately is, members should have the opportunity to make that decision with complete information and a clear understanding of the consequences.
We are asking for transparency, a clear plan and meaningful member consultation before significant changes are approved.
If you have questions or concerns about the proposed changes, we want to hear from you.
Don't let a major decision about the future of your organization happen without your voice being heard.
Review. Ask. Discuss. Vote.
Vote no on Motions 5 and 8You do not need anyone's permission to ask your own board a question. Take these with you.